BJD MP Questions NALCO’s Joint Venture For Angul Power Plant, Seeks Financial Justification

Bhubaneswar: Biju Janata Dal (BJD) Rajya Sabha MP and Member of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Coal, Mines and Steel, Dr Sasmit Patra, has written to the Chairman-cum-Managing Director of National Aluminium Company Limited (NALCO), Brijendra Pratap Singh, seeking detailed clarifications on the proposed 50:50 joint venture between NALCO and NLC India Limited for a 1,080 MW captive thermal power project at Angul in Odisha.In the letter dated November16, Patra, who represents Odisha in the Rajya Sabha, has questioned the commercial wisdom of the arrangement. He noted that NALCO already operates a 1,200 MW captive power plant, possesses established infrastructure and coal linkages, and produced 4 million tonnes of coal from its Utkal-D and Utkal-E mines in FY 2025-26. The company’s recent strong financial performance, he said, further warrants an examination of the independent execution option.The fundamental question raised by the MP is: Why should NALCO, with its existing capabilities and resources, surrender 50% equity in a new captive power project intended exclusively for its own requirements, rather than develop and operate it independently?Dr. Patra has sought specific clarifications on the following points under his parliamentary oversight responsibilities:Independent Execution: Whether a NALCO-owned and operated project was evaluated against the proposed joint venture, and what comparative techno-economic assessment established that surrendering 50% equity would deliver superior financial and operational outcomes.Financial Justification: Details of the approved project cost (with reported estimates ranging from ₹12,000 crore to ₹17,000 crore), comparative financing costs, projected power tariffs, returns on investment, and lifetime financial benefits under both models.Coal Security: Reasons for entering a separate long-term coal supply arrangement with NLCIL’s Machhakata mine when NALCO already has its own Utkal-D and Utkal-E mines and existing coal linkages, along with the operational status of the Machhakata mine and comparative delivered coal costs.Ownership and Assets: Specific contributions from NLCIL that justify equal ownership, and how NALCO’s existing land, water, railway connectivity, ash-handling facilities and other infrastructure will be valued, utilised and commercially compensated.Long-Term Financial Exposure: Justification for NALCO committing to purchase 100% of the project’s electricity for 25 years while holding only 50% equity, including details on tariff-setting, profit-sharing, governance, risk-allocation provisions, and protection of NALCO’s long-term interests.Project Status and Delays: Current status of incorporation, approvals, financing and implementation, and measures to ensure timely commissioning alongside NALCO’s proposed smelter expansion by 2030-31, given past delays in the company’s expansion projects.Dr. Patra emphasised that a public sector investment of this magnitude must be justified by demonstrable economic advantage, not merely by the convenience of an inter-PSU partnership. The decisive test, he stated, is whether NALCO and its shareholders are financially better off under the proposed arrangement than through independent execution.As an MP representing Odisha and a member of the Parliamentary Standing Committee, Dr. Patra underlined his responsibility to seek transparency, financial prudence and accountability in decisions affecting NALCO’s strategic assets and the long-term economic interests of Odisha.He has requested an early, point-wise written response supported by comparative techno-economic feasibility reports, financial evaluations and relevant Board-approved rationale to enable informed examination of the representations received and the concerns raised in the public domain.